Getting it Wrong - How Canadians Forgot Their Past and Imperilled Confederation 🔍
Romney, Paul , 1945- University of Toronto Press, Scholarly Publishing Division, 1999 jan 31
英语 [en] · PDF · 19.7MB · 1999 · 📘 非小说类图书 · 🚀/lgli/lgrs/nexusstc/upload/zlib · Save
描述
and Reconciliation Commission, has said, 'If you don't have some accepted history, the chances are you will not gel as a community.' This provocative book explains how divergent views of Canada's past have sown dissension between Québécois and other Canadians.
Paul Romney reminds us that both French and English Canadians once regarded Confederation as a compact of provinces and peoples, designed to enable each partner to cultivate its own distinct society. With the rise of Canadian nationalism, English Canadians forsook this conception for a centralist myth, which alienated French Canadians by its celebration of nation building and exaltation of federal power. Romney explains how English Canada's forgetting of the original vision led to a 'historic blunder' -patriation of the Canadian constitution without Quebec's consent.
Lively yet learned, Getting It Wrong speaks to Canada's present condition. By disclosing a lost middle ground between the Canadian nationalist and Quebec nationalist visions of Canada's history, it offers us a new way to share our past and thus, our future.
'If I have seen further,' wrote Isaac Newton, 'it is because I was standing on the shoulders of Giants.' Such an acknowledgment is obligatory in a book of this sort, where one is forced to dwell on the errors of earlier writers while taking their achievements for granted. Let me emphasize that disagreement does not signify disrespect. This book owes as much or more to what other historians have got right as to what they may have got wrong.
The book is about political ideas, and I am especially indebted to the work of three historians whose achievement and example permeate it far beyond anything that endnotes can register. I refer to the writing of J.M.S. Careless on Upper Canadian politics, S.F. Wise on Ontario's political culture, and Ramsay Cook on Canadian political ideas and constitutional history. Other writings that I have found especially useful include Carl Berger's The Writing of Canadian History, A.I. Silver's The French-Canadian Idea of Confederation, Robert Vipond's Liberty and Community, and Doug Owram's The Government Generation. In a class of its own is that powerhouse of historical scholarship, The Dictionary of Canadian Biography.
I owe a special debt of gratitude to Richard Risk for a decade and more of fascinating talk about the Canadian constitution and its scholars. Dick also criticized part of the manuscript. Others who graciously read part or all of it, charged with telling me where it didn't make sense or might be improved, are
备用文件名
nexusstc/Getting it Wrong: How Canadians Forgot Their Past and Imperilled Confederation/55fecb529ee0ca8c6572d78be58a7944.pdf
备用文件名
lgli/Getting It Wrong.pdf
备用文件名
lgrsnf/Getting It Wrong.pdf
备用文件名
zlib/History/Paul Romney/Getting it Wrong - How Canadians Forgot Their Past and Imperilled Confederation_3410049.pdf
备选标题
Getting it wrong : how Canadians forgot their past and imperriled confederation
备选标题
Defenders of the scroll : history, legend and lore
备选标题
Ancient Inheritance
备选标题
Terror's shadow
备选标题
Life's Remnants
备选作者
written by Shiraz; Art by Steve Criado
备选作者
Shiraz Baboo; Steve Criado
备选作者
Vetere, Rita
备选作者
Paul Romney
备选作者
Kerry Jones
备选作者
Gene Black
备用出版商
iUniverse, Inc.
备用出版商
Lyrical Press
备用出版商
Kerry Jones
备用出版商
Worcaly
备用版本
University of Toronto Press, Toronto, 1999
备用版本
United States, United States of America
备用版本
Canada - English Language, Canada
备用版本
New York, New York State, 2008
备用版本
Bloomington, In, 2009
备用版本
November 27, 1999
备用版本
Toronto, c1999
备用版本
Toronto, 2017
备用版本
1, 19991110
备用版本
1, PT, 1999
备用版本
2008-11-18
备用版本
74, 1999
元数据中的注释
0
元数据中的注释
lg2168626
元数据中的注释
{"isbns":["1442675314","9781442675315"],"last_page":320,"publisher":"University of Toronto Press"}
备用描述
<p>On a snowy November day in 1872, the premier of Ontario is speaking in his constituency, and he tells a story - the story of his people's long struggle for liberty ...</p>
<p>With this vignette Paul Romney leads us onto a lost middle ground between conflicting visions of Canada's past. He reminds that both French and English Canadians once regarded Confederation as a compact of provinces and of peoples, designed to permit each partner to cultivate its own distinct society. In English Canada that original conception gave way to a nationalist myth, which alienated French Canadians by its celebration of nation-building and exaltation of federal power. English Canada's forgetting resulted in a "historic blunder" - patriation of the Canadian constitution without Quebec's consent.</p>
<p>How did that happen? Romney presents the politics of nineteenth-century Ontario as a confrontation between two competing myths - one of resistance to subversion, and one of resistance to oppression. The latter sustained a long struggle for local autonomy, leading successively to colonial self-government, Confederation, and the entrenchment of provincial rights. It fitted well with the French-Canadian idea of Confederation. But immigration, industrialization and a growing sense of Canadian nationhood transmuted both myths into rival nationalisms - one liberal and anti-British, the other conservative and anti-American, but both of them centralist in orientation.</p>
<p>Ranging across two centuries, this provocative book reveals Canadians in confrontation with the Americans, the British, and each other. It argues that prospects for Canadian unity must depend on recognizing Confederation's true complexity as a compact of peoples and provinces, and on reconciling English-Canadian and Quebecois understandings of Canada's past.</p>
<p>Lively yet learned, Getting it Wrong is a history book that speaks to Canada's present condition.</p>
备用描述
MuPDF error: syntax error: invalid key in dict
MuPDF error: syntax error: invalid key in dict
MuPDF error: syntax error: invalid key in dict
MuPDF error: syntax error: invalid key in dict
MuPDF error: syntax error: invalid key in dict
MuPDF error: syntax error: invalid key in dict
MuPDF error: syntax error: invalid key in dict
MuPDF error: syntax error: invalid key in dict
MuPDF error: syntax error: invalid key in dict
CONTENTS 8
ACKNOWLEDGMENTS 10
1 Introduction: 'The Hard Light of History' 14
Part One. 1820–1850: Reformers and Responsible Government 30
2 Reform versus Loyalism: Two Canadian Myths 32
3 Strangers in Their Own Land 44
4 A Federal Constitution: Reformers and the Empire 53
5 Myths of Responsible Government 68
Part Two. 1850–1890: The Confederation Compact 84
6 'One Great Confederation' 86
7 Confederation: The Untold Story 98
8 Je me souviens: The Great Fight for Responsible Government, Part III 120
9 Peoples and Pacts 135
Part Three. 1890–1940: Forgetting the Compact 156
10 Amending the Constitution 158
11 Centralist Revolution 172
12 Continentalism, Imperialism, Nationalism 192
13 English Canada Forgets 211
Part Four. 1940–1982: Continentalism and Nationalisms 224
14 The New Canadian Nationalism 226
15 Canadian Nationalists and the Quiet Revolution 247
16 A Historic Blunder: Trudeau and Patriation 269
17 Conclusion: Getting It Wrong, Putting It Right 288
NOTES 304
INDEX 330
备用描述
Archbishop Desmond Tutu, chairman of South Africa's Truth and Reconciliation Commission, has said: 'If you don't have some accepted history, the chances are you will not gel as a community.' This provocative book explains how divergent views of Canada's past have sown dissension between Quebecois and other Canadians.Paul Romney reminds us that both French and English Canadians once regarded Confederation as a compact of provinces and peoples, designed to enable each partner to cultivate its own distinct society. With the rise of Canadian nationalism, English Canadians forsook this conception for a centralist myth, which alienated French Canadians by its celebration of nation-building and exaltation of federal power. Romney explains how English Canada's forgetting of the original vision led to a 'historic blunder' -- patriation of the Canadian constitution without Quebec's consent.Lively yet learned, Getting It Wrong is a history book that speaks to Canada's present condition. By disclosing a lost middle ground between the Canadian nationalist and Quebec nationalist visions of Canada's past, it offers us a new way to share our past and thus our future.
备用描述
Far away in the realm of Mythos, an evil entity has broken free of its prison to darken the land. However, entrusted with her father's magic scroll-the only hope for the realm-young princess Dara summons six heroes from different times and places to defend her: a hardened Roman legionnaire, a swift Japanese samurai, a mighty African warrior, a fiery Amazon archer, a spirited Shaolin monk, and a guitar-playing high school student named Alex.
备用描述
Pt. 1. 1820-1850: Reformers And Responsible Government -- Pt. 2. 1850-1890: The Confederation Compact -- Pt. 3. 1890-1940: Forgetting The Compact -- Pt. 4. 1940-1982: Continentalism And Nationalisms. Paul Romney. Includes Bibliographical References (p. [293]-318) And Index.
备用描述
This provocative book explains how divergent views of Canada's past have sown dissension between Québécois and other Canadians, disclosing a lost middle ground between the Canadian nationalist and Québec nationalist visions of Canadian history
开源日期
2018-01-05
更多信息……

🚀 快速下载

成为会员以支持书籍、论文等的长期保存。为了感谢您对我们的支持,您将获得高速下载权益。❤️

🐢 低速下载

由可信的合作方提供。 更多信息请参见常见问题解答。 (可能需要验证浏览器——无限次下载!)

所有选项下载的文件都相同,应该可以安全使用。即使这样,从互联网下载文件时始终要小心。例如,确保您的设备更新及时。
  • 对于大文件,我们建议使用下载管理器以防止中断。
    推荐的下载管理器:JDownloader
  • 您将需要一个电子书或 PDF 阅读器来打开文件,具体取决于文件格式。
    推荐的电子书阅读器:Anna的档案在线查看器ReadEraCalibre
  • 使用在线工具进行格式转换。
    推荐的转换工具:CloudConvertPrintFriendly
  • 您可以将 PDF 和 EPUB 文件发送到您的 Kindle 或 Kobo 电子阅读器。
    推荐的工具:亚马逊的“发送到 Kindle”djazz 的“发送到 Kobo/Kindle”
  • 支持作者和图书馆
    ✍️ 如果您喜欢这个并且能够负担得起,请考虑购买原版,或直接支持作者。
    📚 如果您当地的图书馆有这本书,请考虑在那里免费借阅。